Square Pizza NYC: Times Square

Steven “BuffaloSteve” 2 months ago

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5-Star! Fantastic pizza! I’m a self-proclaimed pizza snob, having grown up in New York and spent years working in the pizza industry. Both slices I tried were authentic, delicious, and reasonably priced. First, I had the classic New York cheese slice, and it was superb. The crust had the perfect crunch on the bottom while remaining soft and foldable, just as a proper NY slice should be. The sauce was packed with flavor and complemented the cheese perfectly. Next was the Sicilian slice with old-world pepperoni, and it was incredible. The contrast of the crispy bottom, light and airy dough, flavorful sauce, and perfectly curled pepperoni made for an outstanding bite. Every component was executed exceptionally well. To top it off, the garlic knot was absolutely outstanding—fresh, flavorful, and one of the best I’ve had. I’ll definitely be back.

Staci 3 months ago

Ordered this while stayed at Crown Plaza HY36 Midtown. It was a 6 min walk from hotel. Ordered using seamless and that’s exactly what it was, seamless!! My order was ready in 15 mins and it was hot and just as ordered. I ordered a gluten free pepperoni & cheese and my son ordered the sausage parm (ziti) and 4 garlic knots. My GF pizza didn’t look like much compared to the regular gluten pizzas in the glass, but looks were deceiving bc it was so good! It was flavor packed and mouth watering. My son said the sausage parm was really good too. He didn’t eat the garlic knots bc he said they were a little hard for his liking but for $4 it’s not a huge loss. If I could have gluten I would have tried one, bc they looked good to me. Pricing was fair, especially for the area. I would 10/10 recommend this place. I am celiac and I did not get sick eating their gf pizza!

Keilah Johnson 4 months ago

I ordered the gluten free + vegan cheese pizza and drumroll….. it was actually tasty!! even though the cheese looks terrible, it’s actually really good!! The bread, although thin, still makes you feel like you’re eating a nice slice. I would come back. I got a square slice with basil, pesto, garlic and mushrooms 😋🤤😋🤤 One star off because it was $9 for a gluten free, vegan cheese slice with 3 toppings. A bit pricey. But honestly I’m used to it. 😂

Max Pena 6 months ago

If you are near Times Square you have to peel off the main drag to stop in this pizza shop. I had the Hot Honey and it was good. Honey with a kick to the taste buds!!! The employees were very nice, welcoming and friendly. And they have a really cool wall with bills of currency from different countries. Definitely RECOMMEND!

mike harris 7 months ago

New york pizza! So good. Pepperoni Pesto, Chicken Bacon ranch Slices and 4 garlic knots. Such a great meal. Very reasonably priced. Very friendly. Great food! Will go back.